|Phyton-International Journal of Experimental Botany
Changes in Phyto-Chemical Status upon Viral Infections in Plant: A Critical Review
1Institute of Agricultural Sciences, University of the Punjab, Lahore, 54590, Pakistan
2Department of Forestry, Range and Wildlife Management, University College of Agriculture and Environmental Sciences, The Islamia University of Bahawalpur, Bahawalpur, 63100, Pakistan
*Corresponding Author: Tehmina Bahar. Email: email@example.com
Received: 12 March 2020; Accepted: 01 July 2020
Abstract: Most damaging plant diseases have been caused by viruses in the entire world. In tropical and subtropical areas, the damage caused by plant virus leads to great economic and agricultural losses. Single stranded DNA viruses (geminiviruses) are the most perilous pathogens which are responsible for major diseases in agronomic and horticultural crops. Significantly begomoviruses and mastreviruses are the biggest genus of plant infecting viruses, transmitted though Bemisia tabaci and members of Cicadellidae respectively. Plants possesses some naturally existing chemicals term as phyto-chemicals which perform important functions in the plant. Some antioxidant enzymes are used by plants for self-defense upon foreign invasion of infection. This review explains the present perceptive of influence of viral infections on phyto-chemicals, oxidative enzymes and biochemical changes occurring in the plant. Viral infection mediated phyto-chemical changes in plants mainly includes: up and down regulation of photosynthetic pigment, increase in the concentration of phenolic compounds, elevation of starch content in the leaf and up & down regulation of anti-oxidative enzymes including (GPX) guaiacol peroxidase, (PPO) polyphenol oxidase, (APX) ascorbate peroxidase, (SOD) superoxide dismutase and (CTA) catalase. These changes lead to initiation of hypersensitive response, by thicken of the leaf lamina, lignification under the leaf surface, blocking to stomatal openings, systematic cell death, generation of reactive oxidative species (ROS), activation of pathogen mediated resistance pathways i.e., production of salicylic acid and jasmonic acid. Collectively all the physiological changes in the plant due to viral infection supports the activation of defense mechanism of the plant to combat against viral infection by limiting virus in specific area, followed with the production of barriers for pathogen, accumulation of starch in the leaf and excess production of (ROS). These strategies used by the plant to prevent the spread of virus in whole plant and to minimize the risk of severe yield loss.
Keywords: Anti-oxidative enzymes; defense mechanism; phyto-chemicals; viral infection
Plant infecting Gemini viruses are present almost everywhere in the world. Therefore, they became a center of scientific considerations related to plant diseases . Among all single stranded DNA viruses ‘geminiviruses’ are responsible for most of plant destructive diseases. Specifically, the group begomoviruses and masteviruses are biggest genus of plant infecting viruses, transmitted by the whitefly and leaf hopper . Plants possess some naturally existing chemicals known as phyto-chemicals which are of two types such as primary metabolites and secondary metabolites . Phyto-chemical analysis of the plant leaf extract, revealed the presence of secondary metabolites i.e., flavonoids, phenols, polyphenols, some antioxidant enzymes, i.e., POX, PPO, APX, CAT and major biomolecules i.e., chlorophyll, carbohydrates, etc. These metabolites are responsible for various important functions in the plants specifically task related to activation of defense mechanism in plants . Any biotic or abiotic stress in plants becomes the cause of change in chemical configuration of primary metabolites and alters the number of phyto-chemicals . Literature confirmed that viral infection affects a lot of physiological and biochemical changes in plants . In 1970 it was investigated that many viruses in different host plants were responsible to change the metabolic activities within the plants . In the past few years it has widely been reported that viruses were not only involved in altering the concentration of phyto-chemicals but also found responsible to stimulate some compounds in plant which activated its defense mechanism against the biotic stress . Interactions between virus and plant have been considered to affect the crop production. Plant virus not only disturbs the secondary metabolites production but also increases their numbers as well. It affects the enzymatic activity of antioxidant enzymes in the plants . PCR results confirmed that begomoviruses also changed phyto-chemicals concentration resulting in activation of defense mechanism . It has been reported that virus altered the secondary metabolites present in the fruit as well. Plant virus involved in increasing the tolerances in plants towards them by activating the antioxidant defense mechanism through enhancing positive biochemical changes in plants . Viral infection enhanced the concentration of phenol, proline and activity of the antioxidant enzymes i.e., CAT, PPO, SOD and POX was also increased due to the viral infection  (Fig. 1).
Objective of this review study was:
1. To elaborate the role of viral pathogens in activation of plant defense mechanism.
2. To understand the phyto-chemicals changes occurring in the plants due to viral invasion.
3. Role of antioxidant enzymes in plant defense activation.
This study will help to further investigate the activation of secondary metabolites in plant upon infection and how they are associated with the activation of plant defense mechanism.
2 Impact of Viral Infection on Phyto-Chemicals
On pumpkin plant, infection of Tomato leaf curl palampur virus (ToLCPMV) affected the chlorophyll content of leaf, this virus affected both chlorophyll a and b, by reducing their amount in the plant . According to Sinha et al. . Banana bunchy top virus (BBTV) upon infection reduced the concentration of chlorophyll a and b, maximum reduction was observed in chlorophyll b than chlorophyll a. Reported reason behind this reduction was the deposition of carbohydrates in the leaf of plant [13,14]. Aucuba mosaic virus in tomato upon infection did not affect the chlorophyll in older leaves; younger leaves have shown no change. Cucumber mosaic disease was supported by the formation of chlorosis strips on the leaf which confirmed the change in chlorophyll concentration in the leaf . It is reported that in tomato, infection of TLCV altered chlorophyll concentration in the plant, decline in chlorophyll concentration was observed in infected leaf as compared to the healthy leaf, increased concentration of chlorophyll was measured at high temperature while low temperature reduced the concentration of chlorophyll . In okra, viral infection decreased the concentration of chlorophyll inside the plant leaf . According to various researchers the Yellow vein clearing mosaic virus (YVCMV) which was responsible for vein clearing mosaic disease in okra caused drastic reduction in the amount of chlorophyll in leaf of okra . It was found that in Egypt (TYLCV) causing infection in tomato reduced the chlorophyll content leading to the reduction of tomato production causing great economic loss to the farmer . It was also reported that Moroccan watermelon mosaic virus (MWMV) infection in Cucurbita moschata caused reduction in both chlorophyll a and b. Their estimation showed that quantity of chlorophyll a was affected more than chlorophyll b . The quantity of photosynthetic pigment should reduce in diseased plants compared to the healthy plants. In eggplant, infection of begomovirus TYLCV which is transmitted by whitefly changed the phyto-chemical and biochemical compounds in tomato, leaf analysis revealed that mild change in chlorophyll concentration was identified . In previous studies, TYLCV was responsible for the reduction of Mg++ which is a main component of chlorophyll . This reduction also led to the decrease of chlorophyll in tomato plant while, high temperature supported the reduction. On TYLCV infection, tomato plant showed chlorosis at high temperature, causing reduction in chlorophyll concentration in the plant . Infection of Bean yellow mosaic virus (BYMV) caused gradual reduction of chlorophyll in Viciafaba infected leaf .
Significant impact of pathogenic viruses on the carbohydrate metabolism of infected plant has been reported. Different viruses caused varied infections in plants such as some completely altered carbohydrate synthesis, and translocation process while others have mild effect . Carbohydrates play a significant role in the plant body but accumulation of excessive starch in the leaf produced viral symptoms  Watson  reported that sucrose contents increased in infected plant on the incidence of viral infection. Carbohydrates have major role in the production of antioxidant enzymes . Strong link between the activation of defense mechanism with carbohydrate concentration has been confirmed by scientific reports [26,27]. Results of Fryer et al.  showed that BBTV infection increased the sugar content by interfering with the photo inhibitory processes in the banana plant and symptoms appeared on infected areas. On the incidence of banana bunchy top infection amount of ROS increased in the plants. ROS sucrose produced within infected plant resulted in chlorosis . In tomato plant decrease in insoluble and soluble sugars in stem and leaf was observed due to infection caused by TLCV in infected plant . Changes in carbohydrates concentration due to viral infection also affect the leaf color, no change was observed in color of healthy leaf while infected leaf showed dark gray color .
2.3 Effect on Polyphenols
Polyphenols are secondary metabolites, which play significant function during host-pathogen interaction, disease development and activation of defense mechanism in diseased plants. Defense mechanism got strengthen by the formation of lignin under the leaf surface that acts as a physical barrier to resist the multiplication of pathogen. This might be due to increased concentration of phenolic compounds upon viral infection in the plants . Enhanced amount of phenol due to the viral infection in plant was measured by Rai et al.  stating that increased amount of phenol resulted in the elevation of plant defense mechanism . Increased levels of phenols also suggested an acceleration of phenol synthesizing pathway following pathogen infection. Anuradha et al.  results showed that the level of total phenols was elevated in P. edulis fruit due to infection of TeMV. Similarly Jaiswal et al.  and Jabeen et al.  have reported that Yellow vein mosaic virus (YVMV) infection in pumpkin plant resulted in increase of phenolic compounds which boasted the defense mechanism in the plant, these compounds were elevated unto 73% in the infected plant leaf while 300% in the infected fruit as compared to the healthy plant. Infection of CMV in tomato increased the amount of phenols which helped in lignifications of cell wall and played role in plant defense by boosting the immunity . The research studies conducted by Jaiswal et al. , Song et al. , Khalil et al. , and El-Dougdoug et al.  also supported the fact that TYLCV enhanced the amounts of phenol in the plants. Huston et al.  reported that infected tomato varieties have more phenolic compounds that activate the resistance phenomena against viruses in plant and also boost the antioxidants in plant for further fight against viral infection. Although, viral infections changed the number of phenolic compounds in plant, but infection of CTV did not show any change in the phenolic concentration . Secondary metabolites specially polyphenols and flavonoid compounds were affected due to viral infection in members of Passifloraceae, results suggested that viral infection enhanced their amounts, in P. edulis fruit by 58.3% while in leaf this increase observed was 43.1% .
3 Effect of Viral Infection of Oxidative Enzymes
3.1 Effect on Peroxidase
First enzyme that is reported to show quick defense against viral infection is peroxidase . Lignification, polymerization, suberification, cell wall elongation, resistance and wound healing are all the processes which are due to POX enzyme . Banana bunchy top infection caused high peroxidase activity in bananas cultivar, while healthy crop showed less POX action in the plant, similar results were observed upon the infection of (TMV) in tobacco plant . Likewise beans infected with (BYMV) , Potato’s infected with potato virus Y , TMV and Tomato mosaic virus (ToMV) causing infection in tomato and bell pepper , TMV infecting tobacco plants , In tomato plants infection of TYLCV , in banana plants infected with BBTV , Capsicum annum infection of Gemini virus  and Cotton leaf curl burewala virus (CLCuBuV) infection in cotton  supported these results. Polyphenol oxidase is involved in AOS process. The accumulation of AOX at the infection site damaged the membrane and destroyed the chlorophyll in the plant which leads to POX during senescence, in green leaves there was a correlation which was observed at the time of increase in POX and decrease in chlorophyll . Peroxidases perform their role in plant defense by the production of pathogenesis-related proteins. POX helped to remove the hydrogen peroxide from the cell. Peroxidase was also found involved in formation of a wall of lignin around the cell which limits pathogens to cross from the place of penetration .
3.2 Effect on Polyphenol Oxidase (PPO)
Plant defense was boosted in the presence of polyphenol oxides, when plant membrane gets damaged on pathogenic invasion, phenols in the plant produced chlorogenic acid, which create an unfavorable environment for the pathogen to spread, polyphenol increased the phenol production that leads to restrict the spread of pathogen . Banana bunchy top infection caused the elevation in PPO activity in banana cultivars. PPO after combining with phenols shows activation of defense in the plant towards pathogen .
3.3 Effect on Catalase
Catalase is an enzyme, which can hold oxygen to protect the cell from peroxides, as peroxides cause toxic effect on plant health by development of H2O2 from substrate [50,51] BBTV supported the activity of CAT in banana leaf, likewise in peanuts the infection of Arachis hypogeal increased the activity of catalase  similarly elevation in catalase was observed when cotton was inoculated with CLCuBuV . The amount of CAT was greater in non-inoculated susceptible cotton variety (CIM-496), in comparison with the non-inoculated resistant variety (NIAB-11) after with the inoculation of elevation of CAT activity reported to be maximum. High activity was observed in genotype Ravi, which was resistant to the CLCuBuV, CAT activity was upto 40%. NIAB-11 showed 34.4% CAT activity, CIM-496 showed 22.22% activity of CAT . In viral infected P. edulis plant the amount of catalase increased upto 52.8% hence the tolerance capacity of plant toward virus also increased said .
3.4 Effect on Ascorbate Peroxidase (APX)
Main role of APX is to hold ROS in plants, activity of ascorbate peroxide was high during BBTV infection in banana, same results were obtained by infection of begomoviruses in Hibiscus cannbinus , Nicotiana benthamiana plant have high APX activity due to infection of Pepper mild mottle virus (PMMV) , Sunflower chlorotic mottle virus (SCMV) infection in sunflower . Over production of ascorbate peroxide boosted the production of peroxidase, led to grip more reactive oxygen species, in past reports it has been stated that the compatible relation between host and pathogen increased the amount of APX in epidermal cells as well as in mesophyll cells, cell itself have no mechanism to restrict the pathogen spread, increased amount of APX allowed cell to remain viable . This mechanism has been studied in Plum pox virus (PPV) infection in apricot . Another report showed that APX activity increased up to 44.6% due to infection of CMV in cucumber plant Jaiswal et al.  and Lan et al.  reported that viral infection increased the APX activity upto 100% due to viral infection of ToLCPMV in pumpkin. In viral infected P. edulis plant the amount of GR increased up to 31.8% hence the tolerance capacity of plant toward virus also increased said .
3.5 Effect on Superoxide Dismutase
SOD reported to be another scavenging enzyme which increases the rate of dis-mutation of SO radical into active oxygen species. Viral infection increased SOD activity in the plant , above statement is supported by the findings of Hernández et al. . It is reported that decrease of SOD in peaches infected with Plum pox virus, Phaseolus vulgaris L. infected with White clover mosaic virus (WClMV)  black gram infected with Urdbean leaf crikle virus (ULCV)  and Soybean mosaic virus (SMV) infection in resistant variety of soybean . Plants enhance the SOD quantity for defense against viral infection . It is reported that Mycosphaerella fragariae infection in strawberry increased the amount of SOD in the infected leave . In resistant variety of Ravi cultivar showed more SOD in infectious plant parts . CLCuBuV infection elevated the quantity of SOD in cotton genotype . Viral infected P. edulis plant the amount of SOD increased up to 66.7% hence the tolerance capacity of plant toward virus also increased said Lan et al. . The behavior of anti-oxidative enzymes and their isoforms were checked in both non-inoculated healthy and infected plants one month later from viral infection. In infected leaf samples there was a substantial increase in the activities of SOD about 273%, in comparison with the leaves of uninfected seedlings .
4 Effect of Viral Infection on Activation of Defense Mediated Pathways
Infection of CMV induced HR response in the plant, salicylic acid production increased in the plant which showed resistance towards pathogen, no increase was noticed in susceptible varieties . Cultivar of tobacco, which was resistant towards TMV produced hypersensitive response, upon infection the level of salicylic acid in infected plant became several fold more than non-infected plant . Infection of Turnip crinkle virus (TCV) on Arabidopsis triggered the hypersensitive response in the plant, but HR response was depended upon the SA but not or JA/ethylene . Infection of cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) in cauliflower plant was investigated by setting three maker genes, for identification of salicylic acid signaling pathway, reactive oxygen and jasmonic acid pathways respectively, results suggested that salicylic acid signaling was very low, but RO and JC acid pathways were visible in virus infecting plant (Fig. 2). PR-1 expression, salicylic signaling was less until 8th post inoculation but then elevated sharply as the viral infection increased. On the other hand, GST1- and PDF1.2 markers which are for observing reactive oxygen species and jasmonic acid signaling showed their elevation upon viral infection after 2 h of post inoculation . It is studied that in tomato, infection of TWV activated plants defense mechanism by stimulating the production of plant hormones i.e., Jasmonate and salicylate  Upon Infection of TuMV in Arabidopsis, levels of SA and ET were more than doubled than the healthy plant, on the contrary JA concentration became four fold in infected plant and continue to increase in infected plants  Infection of citrus exocortis virus CEVd and Tomato mosaic virus (ToMV) also elevated the jasmonic acid production up to 150 folds  According to past researches protein C2 that encodes for Beat beet severe curly top virus (BSCTV) caused the rise of salicylic defense pathway  Likewise in peas infection of Clover yellow vein virus (CIYVV) was responsible for activation of hypersensitive response in diseased plants ultimately leading towards cell death. Wild strain of CIYVV was responsible for cell death in peas. Furthermore, the aggressiveness of CIYVV strain in susceptible peas increased due to SA production . Pathogen identification with the help of R gene was studied; results concluded that upon infection plant showed hypersensitive response, boost the production of reactive oxygen species and up regulate salicylic acid which results in activation of local as well as systemic gene involved in defense. In tobacco activation of N-gene due to infection of TMV produced pathogen related proteins and establishment of SAR on plant pathogen interaction  Citrus leprosis virus C which is responsible for Leprosis disease in citrus, triggered the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) upon interaction with mites which were non viruliferous, plants locally produced ROS and activates the production of the salicylic acid (SA) and jasmonate pathways. On the other hand, JA pathway activating genes were suppressed upon viral infection. Viral infection intensified the ROS burst and cell death and enhanced the expression of genes involved in the RNA silencing mechanism and SA pathway .
From present review it is summarized that upon viral infections in the plants due to the activation of secondary metabolism pathway based on ecological influence and adaptability of genetic code of the plant cell, some naturally existing primary metabolites synthesized into secondary metabolites or phyto-chemicals . Some important secondary metabolites are flavonoids, phenols, polyphenols, some antioxidant enzymes i.e., POX, PPO, APX, CAT and major biomolecules, i.e., chlorophyll, carbohydrates etc. These metabolites perform task related to activation of defense mechanism in plants. Upon viral infection plant activates its defense mechanism to deal with foreign invasion. Generally, two types of defense responses are shown by the plant towards infection, i.e., structural defense and biochemical defense [10,34]. Certain enzymes like chitinase, peroxidases help to give structural defense by controlling the multiplication of virus, furthermore polymerization, suberification, cell wall elongation, resistance and wound healing are all the processes which provide structural defense and are triggered by POX enzyme. Viral infection in many plants increased the activity of superoxide dismutase and polyphenol oxidase, resulting in enhancement of reactive oxygen species that ultimately activate plant defense mechanism . Along with these enzymes, phenols have association with plant defense and the enzymes play a role as a biomarker for plant-viral interaction study [5,47,74]. In biochemical defense mechanism specific pathways are activated which include PR-pathways, PAL pathway, ROS pathways etc., and boost the plant defense by producing secondary metabolites. Concentration of phenolic compounds increased in infected plant resulting in lignifications under the infected leaf surface that act as barrier to pathogenic viruses to multiply in the host cell. Infection of virus induces HR response in the plant cells. Salicylic acid production increased in the plant having resistanance towards pathogen . Cultivars which have resistance against viral pathogen produce hypersensitive response, upon infection the level of salicylic acid became several folds high in infected plants as compare to the non-infected plants [64,68–70] causing disturbance in primary metabolites and antioxidant enzymes activity within the plant. Viral infection enhances the enzymatic activity of the antioxidant’s enzymes, i.e., CAT, PPO, SOD and POX was also increased due to the viral infection . Host plant infected with pathogenic viruses show severe reduction in photosynthetic pigment and chlorophyll content due to accumulation of carbohydrates in leaves tissue. Some specific viruses cause decrease in chlorophyll a and some has effects on chlorophyll b. Due to reduction in chlorophyll, plant undergo chlorosis. Reactive oxygen species production enhanced at the site of necrosis, showing hypersensitive response against viral infection. This review suggests that virus induce resistance in plant by altering the primary phyto-chemicals and antioxidant enzymes to initiate defense mechanism of the host plant. So that plant may thus combat viral invasion as other type of stresses mostly due to presence of natural antioxidants .
This study will help to further investigate that what is the genetic difference among cultivars which shows more resistance against viral strain as compared to the susceptible cultivars. Is there any gene involved which is controlling the defense mechanism and making them more resistant? Is there any gene which is controlling the production of secondary metabolites? Moreover, as secondary metabolites are boosting defense mechanism in plant, is there any other way to trigger the production of secondary metabolites other than viral infections? These are the questions which can be addressed with further research.
Funding Statement: The authors received no specific funding for this study.
Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest to report regarding the present study.
1. Jeske, H. (2009). Geminiviruses. In: TT viruses, pp. 185–226. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer.
|This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.