Open Access

ARTICLE

Techno-Economic Comparison of Electrochemical Batteries and Supercapacitors for Solar Energy Storage in a Brazil Island Application: Off-Grid and On-Grid Configurations

Alex Ximenes Naves¹, Gladys Maquera², Assed Haddad¹, Dieter Boer^3,*

1 Environmental Engineering Program, Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, 21941-901, Brazil
2 Faculty of Engineering and Architecture, Peruvian Union University, Juliaca, 21101, Peru
3 University Rovira i Virgili, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Av. Països Catalans, 26, Tarragona, 43007, Spain

* Corresponding Author: Dieter Boer. Email:

(This article belongs to the Special Issue: Selected Papers from the SDEWES 2024 Conference on Sustainable Development of Energy, Water and Environment Systems)

Energy Engineering 2025, 122(7), 2611-2636. https://doi.org/10.32604/ee.2025.061971

Received 07 December 2024; Accepted 13 May 2025; Issue published 27 June 2025

Abstract

The growing concern for energy efficiency and the increasing deployment of intermittent renewable energies has led to the development of technologies for capturing, storing, and discharging energy. Supercapacitors can be considered where batteries do not meet the requirements. However, supercapacitors in systems with a slower charge/discharge cycle, such as photovoltaic systems (PVS), present other obstacles that make replacing batteries more challenging. An extensive literature review unveils a knowledge gap regarding a methodological comparison of batteries and supercapacitors. In this study, we address the technological feasibility of intermittent renewable energy generation systems, focusing on storage solutions for PVS energy. We propose a framework according to one of the essential parameters for their application in PVS: Energy Density or Specific Energy (Wh/kg). Through computational modelling, issues related to the intermittency and seasonality of the solar energy source are addressed, evaluating the possible benefits of implementing batteries, supercapacitors, and hybrid solutions in renewable energy generation systems. Also, the characteristics of two hypothetical configurations of photovoltaic systems, off-grid and on-grid, were analysed. This analysis highlights the characteristics of totally isolated systems (e.g., on an island or remote village) and systems connected to the grid (e.g., solar farms), where eliminating the use of batteries can bring significant benefits, in addition to tax incentives, which are decisive in the investment decision-making process. The results clarify the viability of PVS and allow an understanding of parameters that can support the technical decision process between isolated or non-isolated systems, reflecting economic and financial issues.

---

Graphic Abstract

---

Keywords

---